Prepaid card debate illustrates fight over consumer bureau

WASHINGTON – Republicans are taking aim at a rule scheduled to go into effect later this year that gives new protections to people who buy increasingly popular prepaid debit and credit cards.

Consumer advocates and Democrats hail the rule, set to take effect in October, but Republicans and industry groups see it is as the latest example of an overly aggressive Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

And they are moving to weaken the agency, itself.

In a statement this week, Sen. David Perdue, R-Ga., called the bureau “a rogue agency more focused on expanding its power than protecting the public.” He introduced a bill Wednesday giving Congress control over the now-independent agency’s purse strings.

Meanwhile, Rep. Jeb Hensarling, R-Texas, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, is said to be planning a proposal to make the bureau director serve at the will of the president.

It would remove the bureau’s ability to impose fines like the $100 million penalty it levied against Wells Fargo, and take away its sweeping powers to create rules like the one on prepaid cards.

The CFPB was created as part of the Dodd-Frank financial reforms, passed after the 2008 financial crisis, and was set up by Elizabeth Warren before she became a Democratic senator from Massachusetts.

Much of the Dodd-Frank reforms were swept away by an executive order by President Donald Trump last week. Democrats are blasting Republican plans to defang the bureau as further indication of Trump going against his campaign promises to fight Wall Street.

Perdue, fellow Georgia Sen. Johnny Isakson and Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., were among eight Republicans who introduced a bill last week rolling back the bureau’s rules on prepaid cards, saying they hurt the customers who rely on them.

The cards, which act like debit or credit cards, allow consumers to load money onto them in advance, and they’ve become increasingly popular, especially among people unable to open a bank account.

About 68 million adults do not have accounts as banks have tightened rules on who may open one, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

In addition, others use the re-loadable cards as a way to limit spending and avoid getting hit with overdraft fees, according to a study by The Pew Charitable Trusts.

The CFPB rules extend to prepaid card users many of the same protections applied to credit cards, including limits on how much consumers have to pay for fraudulent purchases and disclosure of fees and conditions.

However, industry groups and Republicans say CFPB went too far in requiring issuers of re-loadable cards to determine whether customers can repay what amounts to a loan before giving them overdraft protection.

Overdraft fees are a major source of revenue for the prepaid card companies, say consumer groups. One company, Netspend, said during an earnings call that it made $80 million to $85 million in overdraft fees last year.

Fees can add up for individual consumers, many of whom already have financial problems, and push them deeper into debt, said Lauren Saunders, executive director of the National Consumer Law Center.

Banks do not have to do credit checks to offer overdraft coverage, she said, but people who use re-loadable cards are more likely to have bad credit histories and need more protection.

In response to the controversy, which parallels debate over the bureau’s proposed rules for payday lenders, Netspend said its customers rely on overdraft protection to get by.

The company declined comment but said in written comments to the bureau, “Consumers may prefer that a utility payment be paid even if a $15 overdraft fee is assessed, rather than incur a late payment fee imposed by the utility company or face having the utility service temporarily suspended.”

Netspend said it already protects its customers, including by giving them 24 hours to balance their accounts before imposing a fee.

The bureau’s rules are so “complex, onerous, costly and difficult to understand,” the company said, they would make it impractical to continue offering overdraft protection.

Anthony Jackson, one of hundreds of Netspend customers who e-mailed the bureau opposing its rules, wrote that he uses the overdraft protection “during those off-pay weeks when I need a little more extra money to make it ’til my next deposit.”

The company argues that existing rules, which require customers to opt-in to overdraft protection, are sufficient.

However, The Pew Charitable Trusts said in its own written comments to the bureau that many checking customers do not realize they have overdraft coverage – until they’re hit with hefty fees.

Nick Bourke, director of Pew’s consumer finance section, called Perdue’s bill “draconian” because it would undo the new rule instead of modifying it.

Nevertheless, Republicans have criticized the agency, funded by the Federal Reserve, for not being answerable to Congress.

A federal court is expected to soon rule on a lawsuit challenging another controversial provision of Dodd-Frank allowing the president to fire the bureau’s director only for cause.

Hensarling, according to a widely reported memo from the Financial Services Committee, would give Trump power to fire CFPB Director Richard Cordray before his term ends next year.

The bureau, however, also has its supporters.

Saunders said it stepped up to enact rules on prepaid card companies when Congress failed to act.

She and other consumer advocates also note that the bureau has returned $12 billion in fines to customers – including the Wells Fargo fine, which came for opening accounts for people without their knowledge.

Warren, in a statement, also noted the fines levied by the agency and said its rules have protected consumers.

“Big bank lobbyists, predatory payday lenders, and their friends in Congress may not like it, but working families know: The CFPB is on their side and is getting results,” she said.

Kery Murakami is the Washington, D.C. reporter for CNHI’s newspapers and websites. Contact him at kmurakami@cnhi.com.

News

Pell City community Easter egg hunt April 6

News

Alabamians Led Nation in Money Lost from Online Scams

Columns

(Review) A sip of spring fiction, with a bit of history for flavor

News

Greater Birmingham Humane Society to assume operations at Pell City Animal Control Center April 1

News

Eden Career Tech chefs thrive at national competition

News

News-Aegis print edition to be delivered Friday

News

Area students recognized for college excellence

News

LES jump rope team perform at chamber luncheon

News

Alabama Republican Party re-elects John Wahl as Chairman

News

Pell City BOE application for appointment available online

News

Move Alabama Physical Activity Challenge kicks off

News

City of Leeds announces 2025 paving projects

News

Locals recognized for academics

News

Nationwide Cattle Inventory Down, No Surprise for Producers

News

Revolution Roofing moves to larger building

News

Alabama Medical Cannabis Commission opens offering for state testing laboratory licenses

News

Massive bounce park returns to Leeds Friday, Feb. 27

News

Cullman County Sheriff’s office temporarily takes over Hanceville law enforcement calls amid HPD indictments

News

EDC celebrates city, county growth at annual investor breakfast

News

ADPH reminds parents of the importance of measles vaccination

News

Pell City Board of Education appointment process moving forward

News

Alabama Extension agent breaks down Red No. 3 ban

News

New pickleball courts project announced for Leeds

News

Alabama legislature seeks to define men, women