Supreme Court to take case on Colorado baker who refused to sell wedding cake to gay couple

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday said it will consider next term whether a Denver baker unlawfully discriminated against a gay couple by refusing to sell them a wedding cake.

Lower courts had ruled that Jack Phillips, the owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, had violated Colorado’s public accommodations law, which prohibits refusing service to customers based on factors such as race, sex, marital status or sexual orientation.

There are similar lawsuits from florists, calligraphers and others who say their religious beliefs won’t allow them to provide services for same-sex weddings. But they have found little success in the courts, which have ruled that public businesses must comply with state anti-discrimination laws.

The court granted the case after weeks of considering it. In 2014, the justices declined to revisit a New Mexico Supreme Court decision that found that a photographer violated a state civil rights law when she declined to photograph a lesbian couple’s commitment ceremony.

Since then, the high court has found that marriage is a fundamental right that states may not prohibit to gay couples.

The Washington Supreme Court found that Barronelle Stutzman, owner of Arlene’s Flowers in Richland, Wash., violated a state civil rights law that bars discrimination in public businesses on the basis of sexual orientation. The court also ruled that the law does not infringe on her free speech.

The Texas Supreme Court is considering a challenge to Houston’s provision that gives the same benefits to spouses of gay workers as it does to those of straight workers. Gay rights activists say the Supreme Court’s 2015 landmark decision in Obergefell v. Hodges should have settled the issue.

In the Colorado case, David Mullins and Charlie Craig visited Masterpiece Cakeshop in July 2012, along with Craig’s mother, to order a cake for their upcoming wedding reception. Mullins and Craig planned to marry in Massachusetts, where same-sex marriages were legal at the time, and then hold a reception in Colorado.

But Phillips refused to discuss the issue, saying his religious beliefs would not allow him to have anything to do with same-sex marriage. He said other bakeries would accommodate them.

The couple filed a complaint, and in 2014, the Colorado Civil Rights Commission determined that Phillips’s action violated state law. That ruling was upheld in Colorado state courts.

News

PCHS career coach Shelley Kaler named ACTE national award winner

Local News

Metro Bank named Moody Area Chamber of Commerce Business of the Year

News

Take to the skies at the 2025 Spray Drone End-User conference

News

Outdoor Alabama: Try Cane Creek Canyon Nature Preserve for a change

News

ALDOT: Prepare for winter weather

News

Ivey invites students to apply for 2025 Summer internship program

News

Winter weather warnings prompt yard, garden preparations

News

Locals named to WSCC President’s, Dean’s Lists

News

Wallace State signs MOU with Samford University

News

Great Grown-Up Spelling Bee returns to CEPA March 6

News

CEPA to debut theater day camp for area students

News

SpringHill Suites Hotel to break ground in Leeds

News

Leeds chamber of commerce hosts luncheon, recognizes community, business leaders

News

‘Remember, Honor, Teach’

News

Area schools receive dictionary project donation

News

St. Clair school board member Scott Suttle named president-elect of state association

News

St. Clair County Farmers recognized

News

Trussville Rotary names December student, teacher of the month

News

Leeds local business campaigns begin Dec. 13

News

Benedictine Sisters to share collection of nativity sets from around the world during Dec. 15 open house

News

Nominations open for Eagle Awards to honor special contributors to Alabama State Parks

News

Retired Brigadier General shares insights on veteran’s issues

News

Panther Pass deadline Dec. 31

News

Celebrating Cranes in North Alabama Jan. 10-12